Canadian butter tarts with flaky pastry shells and glossy brown sugar filling on a plate

Canada • Regional Dish • Pastry

Canadian Butter Tarts

Flaky pastry shells filled with a rich brown sugar and butter custard. Sweet, gooey and a staple of Canadian baking tradition.

Servings12
Prep Time20 min
Cook Time20 min
DifficultyEasy
Print Recipe

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 200°C. Place tart shells on a baking tray.
  2. In a bowl, whisk melted butter and brown sugar until smooth.
  3. Add eggs, vanilla, vinegar and salt. Whisk until fully combined but not foamy.
  4. Stir in raisins or pecans if using.
  5. Spoon filling evenly into tart shells, filling each about three-quarters full. Do not overfill.
  6. Bake 15–20 minutes until pastry is golden and filling is set around the edges but slightly soft in the centre.
  7. Remove from oven and cool in pan for 10 minutes. Transfer to a rack to cool completely.

Cultural Context

Butter tarts look modest until Canadians start arguing about them. Then it’s not pastry anymore. It’s identity, family tradition and whether raisins belong in dessert or should be reported to authorities.

They’re especially associated with Ontario and Victoria, where printed recipes appeared in community cookbooks in the early 1900s, but their appeal travels well. The magic is simple: flaky shell, rich filling and a soft centre that makes people hover near the cooling rack with fake casualness. Pecans have fans. Raisins divide households. Plain versions keep the peace, mostly.

Fun Fact

It’s not a Constitutional crisis, but Canadians can’t agree whether Butter Tarts should contain raisins or not.

Cook’s Tip

Chopped pecans can replace raisins or omit both for plain butter tarts. Dark brown sugar gives deeper flavour but light brown sugar works well.

Trivia

Midland, Ont. is the Butter Tart Capital of Canada and hosts a major festival attracting crowds and an alarming number of tarts.

More Canadian Recipes

Keep cooking Canada

View all Canada recipes →